Pirates and Privateers
The History of Maritime
Piracy
Cindy Vallar, Editor
& Reviewer
P.O. Box 425,
Keller, TX 76244-0425
Books for Adults ~ Biography: Navy
Seamen & Merchant Sailors
Cindy's
Review
Kristine's
Review
From Forecastle to Cabin
Captain Samuel Samuels
Seaforth, 2012, ISBN 978-0-571-27319-5, US $27.95 /
£13.99
Influenced
by the seafaring tales of Captain Frederick
Marryat and James Fenimore Cooper, eleven-year-old
Samuel Samuels runs away from home to become a
sailor. His autobiography recounts his life as a
seaman, from his days as a lowly cabin boy on a
coastal schooner to his tenure as captain of the
famous Liverpool packet Dreadnought.
During his fifty-year career, he survives “storm
and shipwreck, famine and disease, press-gangs and
desertion, piracy, violence, and mutiny.” (1) He
even rescues a woman from a harem.
This book, the
eighth volume in the Seafarers’ Voices series,
uses the text from the 1877 edition, published by
Harper, and includes some details about the mutiny
of the Dreadnought from Basil Lubbock’s The
Western Ocean Packets (1925). The text has
been shortened, but the omissions pertain to
“repetitious sailing passages and . . . elaborate
technical details relating to the handling of
sails and rigging . . .”. (xi) This volume
includes a map that highlights the various ports
to which Samuels sails.
As Vincent
McInerney points out in his introduction, the
importance of Samuels’s book is that it
demonstrates how a man, who begins his career as a
lowly seaman, can advance to captain a ship, and
how his views of seafaring life change as he
matures and advances. His recounting of the mutiny
aboard Dreadnought is spine-tingling yet
matter of fact. At other times, his tale is
harrowing – such as when he encounters a ghost or
discovers a mate who commits suicide – or
astounding as when he talks about the armament on
one ship. To defend themselves against pirates who
prey on ships in Chinese waters, his vessel
carries “four carronades and six ‘Quakers’ (mock
cannon bolted to the bulwarks which, with
painted-on gun ports, give the appearance of a
sloop-of-war.” (79) Rather than romanticizing his
seafaring life, Samuels wishes to show the reality
of it.
I
would not commit my experiences to paper if I
felt that they would in the slightest tend to
induce a boy to become a sailor. The rough
experience I have gone through, few could live
to endure. I have seen many a man who started
with me in this race of a daring and reckless
life fall early on the journey, leaving his
mother, wife, or sweetheart to watch and wait
for one who will never return to her loving
embrace, or meet her again until the sea shall
be called to give up its dead. (4)
How he ends his
narrative is just as compelling as how he begins,
and his words will haunt readers long after they
close the cover.
Review Copyright ©2012 Cindy Vallar
From Forecastle to Cabin
Captain Samuel Samuels
Seaforth, 2012, ISBN 978-0-571-27319-5, US $27.95 /
£13.99
reviewed by Kristine
Crimmins
This handy-sized version of a much
longer accounting of American Captain Samuel
Samuels's growth and learning experiences on and
off several vessels, the most famous being the Dreadnought,
made a quick and easy read for this reviewer.
Being interested in journals and logs of
voyages, I found it enlightening to read how
Captain Samuels grew up and learned to handle
just about any situation presented a seafaring
young man in the 19th century.
Samuel Samuels
learned to live on pennies a day, survive
prison, and set his own broken leg bone; these
are only some of the intolerable pains to which
most anyone else would succumb. Aging fast,
dealing with every imaginable situation and
human tragedy, and having the opportunity to see
and do what most could not, seems to be the best
and worse of a world Samuel endured. It was a
lifestyle in need of every prayer known to man.
The story reads
quickly as I stated, but it also includes much
detail. Each tale is presented in a way to be
savored and enjoyed. Having sailed various sized
vessels myself, it intrigued me to read every
written word and absorb each colorful entry. I
found myself circling phrases and returning
later to reread and savor the facts of how
Samuels dealt with the situation. I know I will
reread this version, and I recommend it to
anyone eager to have a quick education on what
it means to be a seafarer willing and eager to
gain a worldly education by starting at the
bottom of the ship and working his way to the
top.
Review Copyright ©2012 Cindy Vallar
Click to contact me
Background image compliments
of Anke's Graphics |